The Question of God

Read the above title by Dr. Armand M. Nicholi, Jr. The author has initially introduced a course on the writings and thoughts of Sigmund Freud (atheist) at Harvard. The classes suffered poor attendances until he introduced CS Lewis (atheist-turned-believer) into the curriculum. He has been teaching for the course for 25 years since. Debates became more lively and in some instances, more heated. Perhaps in teaching solely one view, the teacher is preaching to the choir. Perhaps this is what makes the world interesting – people with diametrically opposed world views participating in the great conversation of mankind. A world with people all singing to the same tune won’t be very interesting, will it?

Read not to contradict, but to weigh and consider

In the book, Nicholi examined human life from the views of Freud and Lewis, one of the unbeliever and the other of the believer. He says that we should look at both views as objectively and dispassionately as possible and let the arguments speak for themselves. However, he acknowledges that no one can remain neutral on such emotionally charged issues. To be told that your world view is predicated on a false premise and that your entire life thus far has been lived in vain? Ouch. He notes that because of the over-arching implications of these views in our lives, we tend to vehemently dismiss or discredit the arguments for the worldview we reject. I especially liked the part where he made a plea for the reader to follow Sir Francis Bacon’s advice to “read not to contradict.. but to weigh and consider.”

After reading their views on the question of whether there is an ultimate creator, of whether there is a universal moral law, and the problem of pain and suffering, among others, I’m must admit I’m ashamed at my own mediocre arguments. Till I learn more, maybe the best course of action is to remain silent. To be fuller in mind and fuller of heart, that is my aspiration for the future.

A wise man told me this..

I think expecting logic and rationality from everyone is impossible. The best that I can think of is to conduct myself with humility and approach everyone with a kind attitude. To learn and unlearn. Sigh. It's tough to be a human.